which of the following is a scientific question

Viren

2 min read

·

15-02-2025

14

0

Share

Which of the Following Is a Scientific Question? Unpacking the Scientific Method

Choosing a truly scientific question from a list requires understanding what makes a question scientifically investigable. Not all questions are created equal; some are philosophical, ethical, or purely opinion-based. A scientific question, however, must be testable through observation and experimentation. Let's explore what distinguishes a scientific question.

What Defines a Scientific Question?

A scientific question possesses several key characteristics:

• Testable: The question must be answerable through observation, experimentation, or data analysis. You need to be able to gather evidence to support or refute a possible answer.
• Measurable: The variables involved must be quantifiable or observable. Vague or subjective concepts are difficult to study scientifically.
• Repeatable: Other scientists should be able to reproduce the experiment or study and obtain similar results. This ensures the reliability of the findings.
• Specific: The question should be focused and clearly defined, avoiding ambiguity or broad generalizations.

Identifying Scientific Questions: Examples

Let's examine some example questions and determine which are scientific:

Example 1: "Is the Earth flat?"

This question, while seemingly simple, is scientific. We can test it through observation (satellite imagery, ships disappearing hull first over the horizon) and experimentation (measuring the curvature of the Earth).

Example 2: "What is the best color?"

This is a matter of opinion and aesthetics. There's no objective way to measure "best" in this context; it's subjective and varies greatly between individuals.

Example 3: "Does fertilizer increase the growth rate of sunflowers?"

This is a scientific question. We can design an experiment: plant sunflowers in identical conditions, applying fertilizer to one group and not the other, and then measure the growth rate of each group.

Example 4: "Should we use more renewable energy sources?"

This is a question of policy and ethics, not science. While scientific data can inform this decision (e.g., data on renewable energy costs, efficiency, and environmental impact), the question itself isn't directly testable through scientific methods.

Example 5: "How does temperature affect the rate of enzyme activity?"

This is a scientific question. Scientists can design experiments to measure enzyme activity at different temperatures, collecting quantitative data to establish a relationship.

How to Approach a Multiple Choice Question

When faced with a multiple-choice question asking which statement is a scientific question, apply the criteria above:

1. Identify the key variables: What is being measured or observed?
2. Can the question be tested? Is there a way to gather data to answer the question?
3. Are the variables measurable? Can the results be quantified or observed objectively?
4. Is the question specific and unambiguous? Avoid questions that are too broad or subjective.

By carefully considering these points, you can accurately determine whether a given question is truly scientific. Remember, the core of a scientific question lies in its testability and the potential for objective measurement.

Further Exploration:

• The Scientific Method: Research the steps involved in the scientific method to deepen your understanding of scientific inquiry.
• Experimental Design: Learn about the principles of designing controlled experiments to test hypotheses derived from scientific questions.
• Data Analysis: Familiarize yourself with statistical methods used to analyze data and draw conclusions from scientific experiments.

By understanding the characteristics of a scientific question, you'll be better equipped to analyze research, design experiments, and critically evaluate information.